Sunday, 25 March 2012

Is SRI Sustainable?


Socially Responsible Investment is taking into consideration environmental, social and ethical implications of business practices.  In the US investment market place approximately $3 trillion out of $25 trillion is socially responsibly invested.  The main approaches to SRI are screening, shareholder advocacy and community investing.  SRI has become much more popular in 1995 there were only 55 SRI funds worth $12 billion in the US and in 2010 this had increased to 250 SRI funds worth $316 billion. (USSIF)

It is argues that SRI can improve a company’s bottom line and therefore improve shareholder wealth. Some studies have suggested that companies with better environmental records appear to have better-than-average returns on assets.  It has also been found that environmental ratings can have a significant impact on firm valuation and customer loyalty.  Companies who are involved in socially responsible activities can survive negative publicity compared to those who do not act socially responsible Bhattacharya (2001) and Klein & Dawar (2004). 

Companies which impact the environment or society negatively are likely to be boycotted. Consumers boycott to affect a firms ethical behaviour.  This usually occurs when a firm is believed to be being unethical.  Consumer power has been increasing and it is much easier to influence a firm’s behaviour with the accessibility of media and technology (Glazer et al, 2010). 

Shell, A large oil producer and provider of fuel, has come under scrutiny from Ogoni people of Nigeria.  This is because even though shell is thought to increase Nigeria’s economy by $30bn the people of Ogoni are getting none of the benefit.  In fact Ogoni is a place of devastating poverty, malnutrition and disease.  They also had many pipes built in Ogoniland to enable Shell to drill there.  There have been many leaks of oil and gas, aquatic life has been killed and acid rain has destroyed the land.  This had devastating affects to Ogoni people who depended on farming and fishing for their livelihoods and has led to deterioration of Ogoni people’s health.

A Fully documented report produced in March 1997 by Vietnam Labour Watch led to a huge boycott on Nike.  The report horrifyingly told of physical and sexual abuse that Nike employees in Vietnam were suffering as well as being paid lower than minimum wage.  Nike have acted upon these allegations by increasing employee pay to the minimum wage but workers in Indonesia say Nike now expects longer working hours and increased production quotas.

An article by the Financial Times suggests there is an exciting new period for sustainable and responsible investment emerging.  The European Commission’s interest in improved consumer information on sustainability strategies and social impact has increased.  Investment management houses are being restructured due to rise in SRI.  According to Mercer’s newly published data on 5000 investment strategies globally, less than half are now in the lowest quartile rating bracket of its ESG ratings.  Henderson Global Investors recently restructured its approach to managing SRI fund by changing to Wheb asset management.  Wheb asset management is part of a sustainable investment group covering private equity and infrastructure.(Financial Times, March 2012)

‘Rabobank is making use of its financial engineering expertise to launch a series of products based on indices derived from the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes and screened for risk. They aim to minimise equity portfolio risks for institutional investors by taking a sustainable investment approach. ’Mr Carr from Rabo thinks that stocks that rank highly in sustainability have better stability in financial markets and offer more consistent results.  Therefore the company has come up with two indices that have equally weighted portfolios of 30 European and 30 global stocks from the Dow Jones sustainability Index.  Mr Carr’s reason for this is he believes stability increases the risk/reward ratio over a long period leading to me stable returns for investors. Financial Times, 2012)

But although SRI can have positive financial impact, increase competitive advantage and increase customer loyalty is SRI sustainable?  Investing in SRI can be more costly to companies.  Hawken (1993) states ‘It is often considered financially uncompetitive for a business to add the cost of maintaining a holistic relationship between economy and ecology. Hawkins (2006 p.8) also says using valuable time, effort and resources on discussing and implementing SRI strategies and activities would conflict with focusing on making or maintaining company profitability.  Investors can be sacrificing exposure to value stocks and small cap which could give them higher expected returns (cbs news, 2011).  Also an increase in SRI fund in the UK could lead to less consumer access through banks and building societies (Financial Times 2012).

Glazer, A. & Kaniainen, V. & Poutvaara, P. (2010) ‘Firms’ Ethics, consumer boycotts and signalling’, European Journal of Political Economy, 26(3) pp. 340-350. Elsevier, NORAhost [Online].
Add references from word doc

No comments:

Post a Comment